Pay per lead vs pay per call vs pay per booked appointment for contractors
Free to sign up. No contracts. Each appointment goes to one contractor and is never shared.
Pay per lead bills you when a homeowner's contact reaches you, and you do the chasing. Pay per call bills you for each qualifying call, and some vendors bill missed calls too. Pay per booked appointment bills you for a visit the homeowner already agreed to, so ask each vendor how it treats a no-show.
Lead vendors sell tree service and pressure washing companies three different things under one word. Pay per lead bills you for a homeowner's contact details. Pay per call bills you for a phone call. Pay per booked appointment bills you for a quote visit the homeowner already agreed to.
The useful question is not which price is lowest. It is when the meter starts, and how much work still sits between that moment and a signed job. The table below answers that, row by row.
StingLeads sells booked quote visits, so we compete with the vendors on this page. Every fact about them comes from their own pages, linked.
How do pay per lead, pay per call and pay per booked appointment compare?
Each cell about a vendor links to that vendor's own help page or terms. The last column describes StingLeads, which bills per booked appointment.
On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see every column.
| Question | Pay per lead | Pay per call | Pay per booked appointment |
|---|---|---|---|
| When you are billed | Angi: once you and the homeowner both show interest, "whether or not you open or respond" (Angi help center). Bark: you spend prepaid credits to respond (Bark terms). | Service Direct: each billable call, and "Unanswered calls are always Billable" (Service Direct help). Google Local Services Ads: each valid lead, including an answered call. A missed call in business hours counts if the caller stays on the line over 20 seconds (Google help). | StingLeads: a flat fee for each booked appointment, paid from prepaid credits. You see the job details and the fee before you open the lead. |
| Who chases the homeowner | You. Angi says leads "are not guaranteed jobs" and you must "follow up quickly." Each request goes to "no more than five pros" (Angi help center). Bark tells customers "a maximum of five Professionals will contact you directly" (Bark terms). | You. Someone must answer live, then qualify the job and book the visit. Service Direct still bills when the "Caller books service with a competitor after reaching you" (Service Direct help). | The vendor. StingLeads reaches out to homeowners in your ZIP codes and books the visit after the homeowner confirms they want the work. You show up and quote. |
| What happens with a no-show | Not on either credit list. Angi lists a homeowner who "does not answer your calls or return your messages" as not eligible (Angi credit rules). Bark returns no credits when the customer does not respond (Bark terms). | Service Direct lists "Caller cancels their Appointment" among calls that stay billable (Service Direct help). Google's pages linked here do not mention no-shows. For changes to booked jobs, Google says to "reach out to customers directly" (Google help). | Depends on the vendor. On StingLeads the visit is booked and the homeowner confirmed it, so a no-show is not credited. A homeowner who canceled before the visit is a real defect. |
| What to ask the vendor | How many pros get this homeowner? Which defects earn a credit, and by when? For a credit, Angi wants a call attempt within 24 hours and a lead under 45 days old (Angi). Bark wants a credit return request within 7 days (Bark). | Is a missed call billed? Can I dispute a call? Service Direct reviews only answered, recorded calls received in the last 7 days (Service Direct). Google no longer credits "job type not serviced" or "geo not serviced" leads (Google). | Is it a set day and time, or only a booking request? Google and Bark bill a booking request as a lead (Google, Bark). Is the visit yours alone? Is a no-show credited? |
Read the table as a map of risk. The earlier the vendor bills you, the more of the chasing, waiting and driving stays with you.
When does each model bill you?
Pay per lead. HomeAdvisor's pro help pages now carry the Angi Leads name. Angi bills a lead "as soon as both you and the homeowner show interest" (Angi help center). You can review the project details and the lead fee first. After that, "You are charged for leads whether or not you open or respond to them."
Angi's lead price is not published in its help center. It says lead fees "change based on task, homeowner location, and demand for the work."
Bark runs on prepaid credits. Its terms for professionals say "To respond to a Bark, you will be required to redeem Credits." For enquiries sent straight to you, credits come off when the customer sends a message, places a call or submits a booking request. Credits bought since 1 November 2025 are valid for 3 months.
Pay per call. Service Direct bills for calls from a new potential customer "seeking a service that your Service Category typically provides" (its help center). Any call that ends in a booked appointment is billable too. Answered calls under 20 seconds, spam, job seekers and callers outside your service area are non-billable.
Missed calls are a different story. Service Direct says "All Missed Calls are considered Billable," because there is no recording to review. Its home page also says pay per call companies "cannot guarantee a certain amount of calls or jobs."
Google Local Services Ads bills per valid lead, and a phone call is one kind of lead. Per Google's help page, a call counts when you answer or call back and speak with the customer. It also counts when you miss a call during business hours and the caller "stays on the line for more than 20 seconds." A voicemail, a message or a booking request counts as well.
Pay per booked appointment. The bill comes later, once a homeowner has agreed to a quote visit on a set day and time. StingLeads works this way: a flat fee for each booked appointment, paid from prepaid credits. You see the job details and the fee before you open the lead.
Who chases the homeowner in each model, and how fast?
With pay per lead, you do. Angi says "Opportunities and leads are not guaranteed jobs" and "You'll need to follow up quickly with the homeowner" (Angi help center). Its credit rules expect a call to the homeowner "within 24 hours of being sent the lead" (Angi credit rules).
Sharing makes speed matter more. Angi matches each request "with no more than five pros." Bark's customer terms say "a maximum of five Professionals will contact you directly" (Bark terms). The first company to reach the homeowner can set the price the others are compared against.
With pay per call, the homeowner rings you, which sounds easier. But the call comes when the homeowner is ready, not when you are. A climber thirty feet up an oak, or a tech holding a surface cleaner, cannot pick up. Under rules like Service Direct's and Google's, a missed call can still bill.
A call that connects is still only a conversation. You qualify the job, agree on a time and confirm it. Service Direct lists "Price Shoppers" and "Cannot agree on pricing" among calls that stay billable (Service Direct help).
With pay per booked appointment, the vendor does that work before you pay. What you still own is the visit: show up on time, walk the property and sell the job. For how sharing changes the numbers, see exclusive vs shared leads.
Who pays when a homeowner does not show up?
A missed visit costs more than its fee. Count the drive out and back, the wait on the doorstep and the estimate slot you could have given someone else. For a visit 25 minutes away, that is close to an hour of the working day, plus fuel.
- Pay per lead: you usually carry it. A homeowner who "decided not to move forward" is "not eligible for credits" at Angi (Angi credit rules). Bark returns no credits when the customer "chooses not to respond to your introduction" (Bark terms).
- Pay per call: you usually carry it. Service Direct lists "Caller cancels their Appointment" among calls that stay billable (Service Direct help). Google's credits cover leads it finds to be "of poor quality, duplicate, or invalid" (Google help). The Google pages linked here do not mention no-shows.
- Pay per booked appointment: it depends on the vendor, so get the policy in writing before you buy. On StingLeads a no-show is not credited. The visit is booked and the homeowner confirmed it before it reaches your calendar.
If a lead has a real defect (a wrong or disconnected number, outside your area, a service you don't offer, a homeowner who canceled before the visit, or a wrong address), report it and we credit it back or replace it. The full list is in our Bad Lead Guarantee.
Two habits cut no-shows under any model. Confirm every visit the day before, and arrive inside the window you were given.
Pay per appointment leads for tree service and pressure washing crews
The two examples below use hypothetical numbers, chosen only to show the arithmetic. They are not StingLeads prices or results, and not any vendor's published prices. Swap in your own figures.
Example 1 (hypothetical numbers): a two-person tree service crew
Say the average sold job is $1,400 and the owner values an hour of office time at $35. The owner compares a month of shared leads with a month of booked appointments.
- Shared leads: 20 leads at a hypothetical $60 each cost $1,200. The owner reaches 11 homeowners, books 6 visits, finds 5 at home and sells 2 jobs. Chasing takes about 10 hours, worth $350. Total: $1,550, or $775 per won job.
- Booked appointments: 6 appointments at a hypothetical $180 each cost $1,080. One homeowner is not home, and that fee stays paid. The owner sells 2 of the 5 visits held. Confirming takes about 1 hour, worth $35. Total: $1,115, or about $558 per won job.
Here the booked visits win. Change one number, though. If the owner sold 3 jobs from the shared leads, the cost per won job drops to about $517, and shared leads win.
The lesson for tree service lead generation: the model matters less than your own reach and sale numbers. A crew whose owner is in the bucket truck all day reaches fewer shared leads.
Example 2 (hypothetical numbers): a pressure washing company selling house washes
Say the average house wash sells for $450, with the same $35 value on an office hour. The owner compares a month of pay per call with a month of booked appointments.
- Pay per call: 16 calls at a hypothetical $35 each cost $560. Four ring while the crew is on a job and go unanswered. Under rules like Service Direct's, they still bill. From 12 answered calls the owner books 7 visits, holds 6 and sells 4. Phone and scheduling time is about 3 hours, worth $105. Total: $665, or about $166 per won job.
- Booked appointments: 7 appointments at a hypothetical $75 each cost $525. Six homeowners are home and the owner sells 4. Confirming takes about 30 minutes, worth $17.50. Total: $542.50, or about $136 per won job.
The gap is smaller here. If someone in the office answered every call, those four missed calls could become visits, and pay per call could come out ahead. For a crew where the owner is also on the ladder, the missed calls decide it.
The most you can afford to pay per appointment
Take your average ticket, times your gross profit share before lead costs, times the share of held visits you sell. In example 2, with a hypothetical 60 percent gross profit: $450 x 0.6 x 4/6 = $180 per held visit.
Then allow for no-shows. Paying for 7 appointments to hold 6 brings that ceiling to about $154 per appointment. Above your own ceiling, a source loses money however good its leads look.
How do you compare offers from different models on equal terms?
Sticker prices from different models cannot be compared directly, because each buys a different amount of finished work. Put every offer through the same five steps.
- Write down the billable event. One sentence per vendor: I pay when... If the vendor cannot finish that sentence, stop there.
- List the work left after the bill. Each step you still own costs time.
- Track what turns into visits, then sold jobs. Keep one sheet: date, source, reached, visit held, sold.
- Divide what you spent by the jobs you sold. A lead that becomes a sale one time in eight carries eight times its price into every job you win.
- Add your hours. Put a value on an hour of chasing and driving, and include it.
For figures to use in step four, see our tree service lead cost guide and our pressure washing lead cost guide.
What should you ask a lead vendor before you pay?
- What exactly am I billed for, and at what moment?
- How many other companies receive the same homeowner, and is that in the agreement?
- Is a missed call billed? Is there a minimum call length?
- For an appointment: is it a set day and time the homeowner agreed to, or a request to call back?
- Which problems earn a credit: wrong number, duplicate, outside my area, wrong service, cancellation, no-show? How many days do I have to report one?
- Is a credit paid as cash, as account credit or as a replacement? Do credits expire?
- Are there setup fees, monthly minimums or a contract term?
For the full checklist, see questions to ask a lead company. For credit rules side by side, see lead credit policies compared.
How does StingLeads bill for booked appointments?
You tell us the ZIP codes you work and when you're free for quote visits. We reach out to homeowners in those areas. When a homeowner replies and confirms they want the work, we book a free quote visit and put it on your calendar with the address. Each appointment goes to one contractor and is never resold. You pay a flat fee for each booked appointment, quoted during onboarding for your market and volume, and larger credit bundles lower it. No contracts and no monthly minimum.
You see the job details and the fee before you open a lead. Payment is by prepaid credits, and there is no public price list. The visit is usually the next day.
A no-show is not credited. The visit is booked and the homeowner confirmed it, so the credit rules cover the defects above. Read the Bad Lead Guarantee, then see how it works for tree service leads and pressure washing leads.
Frequently asked questions
Do pay per call vendors charge for missed calls?
Some do. Service Direct says unanswered calls are always billable. Google Local Services Ads bills a missed call in business hours when the caller stays on the line over 20 seconds. Ask each vendor before you start.
Does Angi give a lead credit when the homeowner never answers?
No. Angi's credit rules list a homeowner who does not answer your calls or return your messages as not eligible for credit. Credits cover cases such as a disconnected number, a project outside your ZIP codes or a duplicate charge.
Is a no-show credited on StingLeads?
No. The visit is booked and the homeowner confirmed it, so a no-show is not credited. If a lead has a real defect (a wrong or disconnected number, outside your area, a service you don't offer, a homeowner who canceled before the visit, or a wrong address), report it and we credit it back or replace it.
Is pay per booked appointment the same as pay per close?
No. Pay per booked appointment bills you once a homeowner has agreed to a quote visit at a set time. Pay per close bills you only after a job is sold. With booked appointments, winning the job is still up to you.
How long should I test a lead source before judging it?
Long enough to see 15 to 20 results through to a sold or lost job, over a few weeks. Cap the spend for the test, track every lead on one sheet, and compare sources on cost per won job.
Get Booked Quote Visits in the ZIP Codes You Pick
Exclusive, pre-booked appointments. No contracts, cancel anytime.
Sources and references (10)
- Angi, Opportunities and Leads: Frequently Asked Questions, help center (opened 10 November 2026). https://intercom.help/angi/en/articles/6221483-opportunities-and-leads-frequently-asked-questions
- Angi, How to Request a Lead Credit, help center (opened 10 November 2026). https://intercom.help/angi/en/articles/11403440-how-to-request-a-lead-credit-for-an-invalid-lead
- HomeAdvisor, Service Professional FAQs, pro help (opened 10 November 2026). https://pro.homeadvisor.com/help/faqs/
- Bark, Terms and Conditions for customers and for professionals (opened 10 November 2026). https://www.bark.com/en/us/terms/
- Service Direct, home page and FAQ (opened 10 November 2026). https://servicedirect.com/
- Service Direct, Understanding Billable and Non-Billable Phone Call Leads, help center (opened 10 November 2026). https://support.servicedirect.com/billable-and-non-billable-leads
- Service Direct, Submitting a Call Lead for Review, help center (opened 10 November 2026). https://support.servicedirect.com/lead-review
- Google, Local Services Help: How leads work (opened 10 November 2026). https://support.google.com/localservices/answer/7195435?hl=en
- Google, Local Services Help: Local Services Ads lead credits (opened 10 November 2026). https://support.google.com/localservices/answer/15100654?hl=en
- Google, Local Services Help: About booking leads in Local Services Ads (opened 10 November 2026). https://support.google.com/localservices/answer/12059717?hl=en